After January 1, 2027: Liability, Insurance, and Enforcement for Non-Compliant Traction Elevators

Code & Compliance

After January 1, 2027: Liability, Insurance, and Enforcement for Non-Compliant Traction Elevators

What building owners and property managers need to understand about insurance exposure, AHJ enforcement authority, and liability risk when a traction elevator remains non-compliant past the 2027 deadline.

H
HydraSafe Brake LLC
••5 min read
After January 1, 2027: Liability, Insurance, and Enforcement for Non-Compliant Traction Elevators

Most of the conversation around the 2027 traction elevator brake compliance deadline has focused on how to complete the work in time. Less attention has gone to what happens if a building does not.

For building owners and property managers, that question is not hypothetical. Enforcement authority, insurance carrier positions, and premises liability exposure are all affected by whether a known code requirement has been addressed. This article covers what the post-deadline landscape looks like for non-compliant traction elevators in jurisdictions where the requirement applies.

What the AHJ can do after a deadline passes

Authorities Having Jurisdiction enforce elevator safety codes through a range of mechanisms. The specific tools available depend on the state, municipality, and the enabling legislation under which the AHJ operates.

Common enforcement actions for non-compliant elevator equipment include operating permits placed on hold, orders to cease operation, civil penalties, and mandatory correction orders with compliance deadlines. In jurisdictions with active elevator inspection programs, a non-compliant elevator that has been identified during inspection may be tagged out of service until the deficiency is corrected.

The National Elevator Industry, Inc. (NEII) and the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) publish model code language, but adoption, amendment, and enforcement are local functions. A building owner should confirm with the local AHJ what enforcement actions are available and what the inspection and reinspection schedule looks like for their jurisdiction. Do not assume that a deadline passing without immediate enforcement means the requirement has been waived.

How insurance carriers treat known code deficiencies

Commercial property and general liability insurers evaluate risk based on the condition of the insured property and the owner's compliance with applicable codes and regulations. A known, unaddressed code deficiency is a material fact in that evaluation.

The Insurance Information Institute notes that insurers can deny claims, reduce coverage, or decline to renew policies when a loss is connected to a condition the insured knew about and did not correct. An elevator incident involving an unintended car movement event on a traction elevator that was subject to a UCM compliance requirement, and where that requirement had not been met, creates a direct line between the known deficiency and the claim.

Some commercial property policies include warranty conditions requiring the insured to maintain the property in compliance with applicable laws and regulations. A carrier that discovers a non-compliant elevator after a loss may invoke those conditions. The specific policy language governs, and building owners should review their coverage with their broker before assuming a claim would be paid in full.

Owners who have not yet begun a compliance project should disclose the status to their broker now. Waiting until after an incident to surface the issue is the worst possible sequence.

Premises liability and the negligence standard

Elevator incidents that result in injury can give rise to premises liability claims. The legal standard in most jurisdictions is whether the property owner exercised reasonable care in maintaining the premises in a safe condition.

A published code requirement with a known compliance deadline is relevant evidence in that analysis. If a traction elevator was subject to an Unintended Car Movement protection requirement under a locally adopted version of ASME A17.3-2020, and the owner was aware of the requirement, and the elevator was not brought into compliance, and an incident occurred that the protection function was designed to prevent, the owner's compliance status becomes a central fact in any litigation.

Negligence per se is a doctrine applied in many states under which a violation of a safety statute or regulation constitutes negligence as a matter of law, removing the need for a plaintiff to separately prove that the defendant failed to exercise reasonable care. Whether elevator code requirements qualify as safety statutes for negligence per se purposes depends on the jurisdiction and the specific statutory framework. An attorney familiar with the applicable state law should be consulted on that question.

What is clear is that a documented, unaddressed code deficiency is a more difficult litigation position than a completed compliance project with a full closeout package.

What good-faith compliance documentation looks like

A building owner who has begun a compliance project but has not yet completed it is in a different position than one who has taken no action. Documentation of good-faith effort matters.

A defensible compliance record includes the equipment inventory identifying each traction elevator subject to the requirement, written confirmation of the applicable code provision from the local AHJ, a signed contract with a licensed elevator contractor, a permit application or permit in hand, and a projected completion date. If the project has been delayed by factors outside the owner's control, such as permit processing backlogs, contractor scheduling constraints, or material lead times, that documentation should be preserved as well.

AHJs in some jurisdictions have formal variance or extension processes for owners who can demonstrate good-faith progress. The availability and terms of those processes vary. Contact the local AHJ directly to ask whether an extension process exists and what it requires.

The documentation the building record needs

Whether a compliance project is complete or in progress, the building record should contain specific materials. For a completed project: the approved submittal, product technical documentation, installation record, test results, AHJ correspondence, and final acceptance documentation. For a project in progress: the equipment inventory, AHJ correspondence confirming the applicable requirement, the contractor agreement, and the permit record.

These materials serve multiple purposes. They are the primary evidence of compliance in an AHJ inspection. They are the documentation an insurance carrier will request after a loss. They are the record a plaintiff's attorney will seek in discovery. And they are the file a prospective buyer's counsel will review in a property transaction.

HydraSafe Brake provides product documentation for technical review and submittal preparation. The consultant, contractor, and AHJ determine the correct application and acceptance path for each elevator. If a compliance project has not yet started, the time to start it is now.

Explore Topics

#elevator liability#elevator insurance#2027 elevator deadline#AHJ enforcement#traction elevator#ASME A17.3#building owner#elevator compliance#property manager
H

Technical guidance published by

HydraSafe Brake LLC

Product and code-context material for elevator project review. Confirm equipment, code adoption, document scope, and acceptance requirements for the specific project.

Read technical content standards